RealTeaNewsInvestigationsNews

How a Secrecy Rule Became a False Account to Three Courts

MI5 has a longstanding practice of neither confirming nor denying whether anyone is an informant. An official investigation found that practice was broken, then replaced with a false story that the courts, a watchdog and a tribunal were all asked to believe.

Published

AI-generated illustration: a black office telephone on a desk beside a closed manila folder and a page marked only with solid redaction bars.
AI-generated image. RealTeaNews (AI-generated illustration)

MI5 has a longstanding practice of neither confirming nor denying — NCND — whether any person is a covert human intelligence source. The High Court has described that practice as “well-established and rarely departed from.”

The Agent X case is the story of how it was departed from, and of how a false account that it had been maintained was then given to three courts. Sir John Goldring, appointed after the Prime Minister directed an inquiry under section 230 of the Investigatory Powers Act 2016, put the point without decoration. Officer 2, then MI5’s head of communications, “throughout knew he had departed from NCND. His lies formed the foundation of MI5’s false account.”

MI5 now accepts that finding without reservation. Officer 2 does not. He has not been convicted of any offence, and he denies acting dishonestly.

A departure that was never authorised

Sir John’s open report, published on 16 July 2026, reconstructed the sequence. In the summer of 2019, Daniel De Simone, then investigating neo-Nazi extremism for the BBC, began researching Agent X and found what the report calls “alarming material online.” On 5 June 2020 he emailed X to say the BBC planned to report that he was a dangerous neo-Nazi. X contacted MI5. His handlers believed a broadcast would put his life in danger, and thought the only way to prevent it was to tell the journalist that X was “not a real extremist, but was pretending to be so at the behest of MI5.”

That would have meant an exceptional departure from NCND. Sir John found that proper authorisation was never obtained. Advice from an MI5 legal adviser was treated as if it were authorisation. Authority was not sought from the director general or a deputy director general, as it should have been.

Officer 2 telephoned De Simone on 8 and 9 June 2020 and, Sir John found, revealed from the outset of the first call that Agent X was an MI5 agent. De Simone made a contemporaneous note of the first conversation and recorded the second. There were further calls, some of them also recorded, in which Officer 2 disclosed whether other people of interest to the BBC were or were not MI5 agents. Sir John concluded that Officer 2 “comprehensively departed from NCND” in “a detailed and wholly inappropriate way,” and made no note of the calls, contrary to policy he himself had recently helped to draft.

The false account is sworn, then repeated

When the BBC later prepared to broadcast a fuller investigation, the Attorney General, acting for MI5, applied in 2022 for an injunction. By then Officer 3 had succeeded Officer 2 as head of communications. In a sworn open witness statement, an MI5 officer known as Witness A told the High Court that MI5 had consistently applied NCND in relation to X. The same account was later given to the Investigatory Powers Commissioner’s Office and to the Investigatory Powers Tribunal in a claim brought by Beth, X’s former partner, and again in her judicial review of the tribunal’s decision to let MI5 maintain NCND.

That account was untrue. Special advocates — security-cleared lawyers appointed to represent the BBC’s interests in closed hearings — queried it after reading X’s case file. On 24 February 2022, Sir John found, MI5 gave them “a wholly misleading and flawed response” that NCND had been maintained. On 7 April 2022 the court granted an interim injunction, made permanent on 5 October 2022. The BBC could report the essential allegations about X’s conduct, but could not identify him.

Beth issued a claim in the Investigatory Powers Tribunal in May 2022, alleging that MI5 had failed to protect her and had breached her human rights. She asked the tribunal to require MI5 to disclose, even privately to her and her lawyers, whether X was a CHIS. In a judgment of 21 June 2024 the tribunal concluded that MI5 had maintained NCND throughout. Her application failed.

Only after that ruling did De Simone correct the record. On 18 November 2024 the BBC told MI5 that Officer 2 had disclosed X’s status from the outset. On 13 December 2024 MI5 representatives were shown De Simone’s note of the first call and heard the recording of the second. On 12 February 2025 the High Court varied the injunction so that the BBC could report that the claim of consistent NCND was false. On 23 May 2025, Sir John recorded, MI5 decided publicly to confirm that Agent X was in fact a CHIS.

Opportunities missed, then an official finding

Internal MI5 investigations, and a review by Sir Jonathan Jones KC, then concluded that there had been no deliberate attempt to mislead the court and that the core problem was a failure to keep records. In a judgment of 2 July 2025, the Lady Chief Justice, Dame Victoria Sharp and Mr Justice Chamberlain rejected those exercises as suffering from “serious procedural deficiencies,” saying their conclusions were not reliable.

Sir John interviewed 36 witnesses and produced open and closed reports. His core conclusions were blunt. Proper authorisation to depart from NCND was never obtained. Officer 3 “did not accurately report what Officer 2 had said,” “misrepresented” him, “shut down” a colleague who warned that “that horse had bolted,” and “bears considerable responsibility for MI5’s continued reliance on the false account.” Witness A “overstated the position” and contributed to the false account being maintained. Agent X’s file contained “cogent evidence” that NCND had been departed from, but “no-one at MI5 sufficiently considered its implications” and “opportunities to correct the position were missed.” The duty of candour, Sir John found, was never in terms explained to Witness A, or to officers whose evidence fed into his statement.

Officer 3, who is suspended and facing disciplinary proceedings, denies through his counsel that he acted dishonestly or with any intention to mislead. Officer 2 resigned during 2025. He accepts that his conduct in the conversations with De Simone fell below the standard expected of him, but denies acting dishonestly.

The official record now shows something more structural than a single unauthorised phone call. A secrecy rule was broken. A false account that it had not been broken was then sworn, repeated, and defended, including in answer to lawyers who had seen the file and asked the obvious question. Sir John found that the opportunities to correct it were there. They were not taken.

Sources

Sources

  1. Sir John Goldring open report, July 2026: https://data.parliament.uk/DepositedPapers/Files/DEP2026-0501/IPCO_Report_on_Agent_X_16_7_2026.pdf, UK Parliament. Accessed 12 November 2026.
  2. High Court approved judgment, 3 November 2026, [2026] EWHC 2802 (Admin): https://www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/HMAG-v-BBC-QB-2022-000174-BETH-v-IPT-AC-2024-LON-002952-Approved-Judgment.pdf, Judiciary of England and Wales. Accessed 12 November 2026.
  3. Official court press summary, 3 November 2026: https://www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/bbc-and-beth-press-summary-nov26-1.pdf, Judiciary of England and Wales. Accessed 12 November 2026.
  4. IPCO, “Investigatory Powers Commissioner publishes report into Agent X Investigation,” 16 July 2026: https://www.ipco.org.uk/news/investigatory-powers-commissioner-publishes-report-into-agent-x-investigation/, Investigatory Powers Commissioner's Office. Accessed 12 November 2026.
  5. Daniel De Simone, BBC News, “MI5 court evidence based on lies, official report says,” 16 July 2026: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/crmrwe84rp2o, BBC News. Accessed 12 November 2026.
  6. Daniel De Simone, BBC News, “MI5 accepts it gave evidence based on lies in neo-Nazi spy case,” 18 September 2026: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c3j4jz07e2v8o, BBC News. Accessed 12 November 2026.

Sources link to external sites. Their content is the responsibility of their publishers.

More in Investigations