
After Agent X, the Courts May No Longer Take MI5’s Word on Trust
The most lasting consequence of the Agent X affair may not be a contempt finding — there isn’t one — but a public warning from the country’s most senior judges that MI5’s corporate evidence can no longer be assumed to be reliable.
Published

When the High Court declined, on 3 November 2026, to bring contempt proceedings over false evidence in the Agent X case, the Security Service was entitled to say that the court itself would not be the prosecutor. Sir Ken McCallum, MI5’s director general, called that welcome. What he could not treat as welcome was the rest of the judgment.
The Lady Chief Justice, sitting with Dame Victoria Sharp and Mr Justice Chamberlain, said the findings of Sir John Goldring’s investigation were obviously serious and would “inevitably affect the confidence that we and other courts and tribunals can have in corporate evidence from MI5.” Those findings, the judges added, “may justify a more searching approach” to such evidence, “including where it contains national security assessments.”
For an agency that has long asked the courts to take its secrecy claims on trust, that warning may prove as significant as the decision not to initiate contempt.
“Failings of candour undermine the entire basis of oversight”
The Investigatory Powers Commissioner’s Office, summarising Sir John’s investigation in July 2026, said he had identified “serious and systemic failures in MI5’s conduct.” Sir Brian Leveson, the commissioner, said: “MI5’s management of Agent X fell far below the standards the public, the courts and IPCO have every right to expect.” An earlier IPCO inspection in 2022 had already identified “significant failings in how Agent X was handled” as a source. “What makes this case particularly grave,” Sir Brian said, “is that IPCO and the courts were misled. Failings of candour undermine the entire basis of oversight and accountability.”
In comments marking the publication of his annual report on 29 October 2026, reported by the BBC, Lord Leveson went further, saying “the case of agent X is as serious as anything I have dealt with as commissioner.”
That is not the language of a paperwork lapse. The official account, accepted by MI5 without reservation, is that false evidence was given to the High Court, to the investigatory-powers watchdog, and to the tribunal to which a woman known as Beth had turned for a human rights claim. Sir John noted that if an MI5 communications chief had disclosed the informant’s status to the BBC, “MI5’s argument that it should not be disclosed to Beth would inevitably be weakened.” Because the courts accepted MI5’s account, information was kept from her.
On 17 March 2026, before Sir John’s report was published, McCallum announced that MI5 had settled Beth’s claim “without admission of liability.” The Centre for Women’s Justice has said she received a substantial payout. MI5 has not published a figure. The settlement was not an admission of liability, and was not an admission that the abuse she alleges was authorised.
Parliament was told the reading was stark
Shabana Mahmood, the home secretary, told Parliament on 16 July 2026 that Sir John’s conclusions made “stark reading” and outlined “a series of failings both individually and organisationally within MI5.” She said she would take “decisive action” to hold MI5 to account and to strengthen the mechanisms by which she holds the director general to account.
MI5 has put in place what it describes as a “comprehensive programme of changes,” overseen by a board which includes a senior Home Office official and on which a senior official from IPCO has speaking rights. After the November judgment, a Home Office spokesperson said the case had “highlighted serious failings by individual MI5 officers” and that the home secretary had “taken decisive action to strengthen her oversight and assurance of MI5 and to hold the Director General to account for MI5’s past mistakes.”
McCallum, in his own statement that day, said the judgment “underlines MI5’s serious failures in this case.” He repeated his apology “for those failures, and for the additional distress they caused to Beth.” Then came the sentence on which the rest of this affair now turns: “The courts, and those charged with scrutinising us, must have confidence that information we provide is accurate and complete. That confidence now needs to be re-earned.”
The gap that remains
Re-earning it is not the same as being held to account in a criminal court. The judges assumed, without deciding, that two senior officers “may” have committed contempt, then said any further action should follow a police investigation, with the CPS considering possible offences such as misconduct in public office or perverting the course of justice. The court would not do that work itself. It would not punish MI5 as an institution either. There was, the judges said, no public interest in a financial penalty whose only effect would be “to deprive MI5 of funds it requires to undertake its important work.” They did order the service to pay the BBC’s and Beth’s costs on the indemnity basis.
The Home Office declined to say, when the judgment was published, whether it would refer the matter to the police. The BBC reported that a source said officials were still considering the implications. As of 8 November 2026, no public announcement of a referral had been identified.
Beth said: “I am deeply disappointed that the court has decided not to pursue contempt proceedings.” The court’s suggestion that the officers’ conduct might amount to criminal offences, and could be referred to the police, did not reassure her. “I cannot help feeling sceptical about whether that will lead to meaningful action,” she said. Kate Ellis, joint head of litigation at the Centre for Women’s Justice, called the decision not to launch contempt proceedings “surprising” and said the Home Office “should also seriously consider referring the accused officers to the police.”
The officers most criticised deny dishonesty and have not been convicted of any offence. Officer 2 resigned during 2025. Officer 3 is suspended and facing disciplinary proceedings. Agent X remains unnamed. Beth remains known only by that alias.
What has changed, on the official record, is the standing of MI5’s word in open court. The country’s most senior judges have said the findings will inevitably affect the confidence they can have in the service’s corporate evidence, including where national security assessments are in play. The oversight commissioner has said that failings of candour undermine the entire basis of accountability. The director general has said that confidence needs to be re-earned. Whether anyone is investigated by the police is, as of the research for this draft, still an unanswered question. The courts have already given their answer about trust.
Sources
- High Court approved judgment, 3 November 2026, [2026] EWHC 2802 (Admin): https://www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/HMAG-v-BBC-QB-2022-000174-BETH-v-IPT-AC-2024-LON-002952-Approved-Judgment.pdf
- Official court press summary, 3 November 2026: https://www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/bbc-and-beth-press-summary-nov26-1.pdf
- Sealed order, 3 November 2026: https://www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Sealed-order-QB-2022-000174-03.11.2026.pdf
- IPCO, “Investigatory Powers Commissioner publishes report into Agent X Investigation,” 16 July 2026: https://www.ipco.org.uk/news/investigatory-powers-commissioner-publishes-report-into-agent-x-investigation/
- Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood, written ministerial statement, Hansard, 16 July 2026: https://hansard.parliament.uk/commons/2026-07-16/debates/26071631000029/InvestigatoryPowersCommissioner%E2%80%99SOfficeReport
- Sir Ken McCallum statements, 17 March 2026, 16 July 2026 and 3 November 2026: https://www.mi5.gov.uk/director-general-mi5-statement, https://www.mi5.gov.uk/director-general-mi5-statement-0, https://www.mi5.gov.uk/director-general-mi5-statement-1
- Centre for Women’s Justice, 3 November 2026: https://www.centreforwomensjustice.org.uk/updates/mi5-lies-may-be-a-matter-for-the-police-says-court-in-case-of-abusive-agent
- Daniel De Simone, BBC News, 29 October 2026 and 3 November 2026: https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c3dxwdwx8vxwo, https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cq5yn64wn2y7o
Sources
- High Court approved judgment, 3 November 2026, [2026] EWHC 2802 (Admin): https://www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/HMAG-v-BBC-QB-2022-000174-BETH-v-IPT-AC-2024-LON-002952-Approved-Judgment.pdf, Judiciary of England and Wales. Accessed 12 November 2026.
- Official court press summary, 3 November 2026: https://www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/bbc-and-beth-press-summary-nov26-1.pdf, Judiciary of England and Wales. Accessed 12 November 2026.
- Sealed order, 3 November 2026: https://www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Sealed-order-QB-2022-000174-03.11.2026.pdf, Judiciary of England and Wales. Accessed 12 November 2026.
- IPCO, “Investigatory Powers Commissioner publishes report into Agent X Investigation,” 16 July 2026: https://www.ipco.org.uk/news/investigatory-powers-commissioner-publishes-report-into-agent-x-investigation/, Investigatory Powers Commissioner's Office. Accessed 12 November 2026.
- Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood, written ministerial statement, Hansard, 16 July 2026: https://hansard.parliament.uk/commons/2026-07-16/debates/26071631000029/InvestigatoryPowersCommissioner%E2%80%99SOfficeReport, UK Parliament (Hansard). Accessed 12 November 2026.
- Sir Ken McCallum statements, 17 March 2026, 16 July 2026 and 3 November 2026: https://www.mi5.gov.uk/director-general-mi5-statement, https://www.mi5.gov.uk/director-general-mi5-statement-0, https://www.mi5.gov.uk/director-general-mi5-statement-1, Security Service (MI5). Accessed 12 November 2026.
- Centre for Women’s Justice, 3 November 2026: https://www.centreforwomensjustice.org.uk/updates/mi5-lies-may-be-a-matter-for-the-police-says-court-in-case-of-abusive-agent, Centre for Women’s Justice. Accessed 12 November 2026.
- Daniel De Simone, BBC News, 29 October 2026 and 3 November 2026: https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c3dxwdwx8vxwo, https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cq5yn64wn2y7o, BBC News. Accessed 12 November 2026.
Sources link to external sites. Their content is the responsibility of their publishers.
More in Investigations
InvestigationsNews
CIA Used Federal Narcotics Officers and Safehouses to Dose Unwitting People “at All Social Levels”
InvestigationsNews
He Claimed That Made Him Untouchable: The Informant Known as Agent X
InvestigationsNews