
High Court Will Not Pursue MI5 for Contempt — But Says Police May Investigate
Senior judges say it is not in the public interest to bring contempt proceedings after an official investigation found that lies formed the foundation of MI5’s account to three courts. If there is to be further action, they said, it should follow a police inquiry.
Published

The High Court has declined to bring contempt of court proceedings against MI5, its director general or individual officers over false evidence given to three courts in the case of Agent X, a covert Security Service informant accused of using that secret status to terrorise his partner.
In a judgment handed down on Tuesday 3 November 2026, the Lady Chief Justice, Baroness Carr of Walton-on-the-Hill, sitting with Dame Victoria Sharp and Mr Justice Chamberlain, said the findings of an independent investigation into the affair were obviously serious and would “inevitably affect the confidence” that courts can have in corporate evidence from MI5. Even so, the judges concluded that it would not be in the public interest for the court itself to start contempt proceedings.
If there is to be further action against two senior officers criticised in that investigation, the court said, it should follow an investigation by the police, “who have the appropriate investigatory powers and resources.” The judges noted that offences such as misconduct in public office or perverting the course of justice might be considered, with the Crown Prosecution Service deciding whether to prosecute.
The court did not find anyone guilty of contempt. It assumed, without formally deciding, that Officers 2 and 3 “may” have committed contempt, and then declined to proceed. A criminal investigation remains a possibility raised by the judges, not a concluded prosecution decision.
What the court was asked to decide
The issue before the Divisional Court was narrow. MI5 had given evidence that it had consistently applied its “neither confirm nor deny” policy in relation to the informant known as X. That evidence, later shown to be untrue, was relied on in the High Court, before the Investigatory Powers Commissioner’s Office and the Investigatory Powers Tribunal, and again in Beth’s judicial review of a tribunal decision.
In July 2025 the same three judges had already made trenchant public criticisms of MI5’s conduct, rejected internal reviews as unreliable, and adjourned the question of contempt pending a fresh investigation. The Prime Minister then directed the Investigatory Powers Commissioner to investigate. Sir John Goldring interviewed 36 witnesses and published an open report on 16 July 2026. One of his core conclusions was that Officer 2’s “lies formed the foundation of MI5’s false account.”
MI5 now accepts those findings without reservation. The two officers most criticised do not. Officer 2 resigned during 2025. Through his counsel he has accepted that his conduct in conversations with the BBC journalist Daniel De Simone fell below the standard expected of him, but denies acting dishonestly. Officer 3 is suspended and facing disciplinary proceedings. Through his counsel he has denied acting dishonestly or with any intention to mislead. Neither officer has been convicted of any offence.
Why the judges stopped short
The court said Sir John’s conclusions would not themselves be admissible against individuals who dispute them. Relitigating the investigation — 36 witnesses, much of the material classified — “could not realistically be undertaken by the court on its own.” Contempt proceedings would be unlikely to do more than duplicate Sir John’s findings.
The judges doubted that the director general, Sir Ken McCallum, could be made personally liable. Even if he could, they said, such responsibility would depend on vicarious liability, which does not imply any personal fault on his part. They also found no public benefit in proceedings against MI5 as an entity. Even if the service could in principle be liable for contempt, the evidence did not demonstrate that the individuals involved were part of its “directing mind.” There was, the court said, no public interest in a financial penalty whose only effect would be “to deprive MI5 of funds it requires to undertake its important work.”
If the police considered they had sufficient admissible evidence of offences — for example, misconduct in public office or perverting the course of justice — they should pass that evidence to the CPS. In a prosecution for misconduct in public office, the court noted, it would not be necessary to prove a causal link between what the officers said and did and the making of the false statement by another officer, known as Witness A.
MI5 was ordered to pay the costs of the BBC and of Beth on the indemnity basis, a more demanding standard than ordinary costs, and to make an interim payment of 50 per cent within 14 days of being served with a schedule.
A door left open
The Home Office declined to say, when the judgment was published, whether it would refer the matter to the police. The BBC reported that a source said officials were still considering the implications. A Home Office spokesperson said the case had “highlighted serious failings by individual MI5 officers” and that the home secretary had “taken decisive action to strengthen her oversight and assurance of MI5 and to hold the Director General to account for MI5’s past mistakes.” As of 8 November 2026, five days after the judgment, no public announcement of a police referral had been identified.
McCallum said the judgment “underlines MI5’s serious failures in this case.” In a statement published by the Security Service, he repeated his apology “for those failures, and for the additional distress they caused to Beth,” and said it was welcome that the court had not initiated contempt proceedings. “The courts, and those charged with scrutinising us, must have confidence that information we provide is accurate and complete. That confidence now needs to be re-earned.”
Beth, whose alias is the only name the courts will give her, said in a statement issued by the Centre for Women’s Justice: “I am deeply disappointed that the court has decided not to pursue contempt proceedings. The Goldring report found that senior MI5 officers knowingly misled the courts, and that those lies formed the foundation of MI5’s false account. These are extremely serious findings which should demand consequences.”
Kate Ellis, joint head of litigation at the Centre for Women’s Justice, called the decision not to launch contempt proceedings “surprising” and said the Home Office “should also seriously consider referring the accused officers to the police.” The judges left that door open. What they would not do is start the prosecution themselves.
Sources
- High Court approved judgment, 3 November 2026, [2026] EWHC 2802 (Admin): https://www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/HMAG-v-BBC-QB-2022-000174-BETH-v-IPT-AC-2024-LON-002952-Approved-Judgment.pdf
- Official court press summary, 3 November 2026: https://www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/bbc-and-beth-press-summary-nov26-1.pdf
- Sealed order, 3 November 2026: https://www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Sealed-order-QB-2022-000174-03.11.2026.pdf
- Sir John Goldring open report, July 2026: https://data.parliament.uk/DepositedPapers/Files/DEP2026-0501/IPCO_Report_on_Agent_X_16_7_2026.pdf
- Sir Ken McCallum statement, 3 November 2026: https://www.mi5.gov.uk/director-general-mi5-statement-1
- Centre for Women’s Justice, 3 November 2026: https://www.centreforwomensjustice.org.uk/updates/mi5-lies-may-be-a-matter-for-the-police-says-court-in-case-of-abusive-agent
- Daniel De Simone, BBC News, 3 November 2026: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cq5yn64wn2y7o
Sources
- High Court approved judgment, 3 November 2026, [2026] EWHC 2802 (Admin): https://www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/HMAG-v-BBC-QB-2022-000174-BETH-v-IPT-AC-2024-LON-002952-Approved-Judgment.pdf, Judiciary of England and Wales. Accessed 12 November 2026.
- Official court press summary, 3 November 2026: https://www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/bbc-and-beth-press-summary-nov26-1.pdf, Judiciary of England and Wales. Accessed 12 November 2026.
- Sealed order, 3 November 2026: https://www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Sealed-order-QB-2022-000174-03.11.2026.pdf, Judiciary of England and Wales. Accessed 12 November 2026.
- Sir John Goldring open report, July 2026: https://data.parliament.uk/DepositedPapers/Files/DEP2026-0501/IPCO_Report_on_Agent_X_16_7_2026.pdf, UK Parliament. Accessed 12 November 2026.
- Sir Ken McCallum statement, 3 November 2026: https://www.mi5.gov.uk/director-general-mi5-statement-1, Security Service (MI5). Accessed 12 November 2026.
- Centre for Women’s Justice, 3 November 2026: https://www.centreforwomensjustice.org.uk/updates/mi5-lies-may-be-a-matter-for-the-police-says-court-in-case-of-abusive-agent, Centre for Women’s Justice. Accessed 12 November 2026.
- Daniel De Simone, BBC News, 3 November 2026: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cq5yn64wn2y7o, BBC News. Accessed 12 November 2026.
Sources link to external sites. Their content is the responsibility of their publishers.